Let’s stop pretending U.S. News & World Report’s college rankings measure excellence. They measure conformity.
For decades, the same universities that built bloated bureaucracies and ideological echo chambers have graded each other on a curve — rewarding peers who protect the status quo and punishing any institution brave enough to change. That’s why their rankings have become a safe haven for mediocrity masquerading as prestige.
At New College of Florida, we’ve refused to play along. The state of Florida is committed to maintaining a public liberal arts college that actually lives up to its mission — where students learn how to think, not what to think.
That college is New College.
And yet, the U.S. News formula punishes reform. Twenty percent of every college’s score — the single most heavily weighted factor — comes from “peer assessment.” In plain English, that means other college administrators — the very people most threatened by real accountability — get to decide who succeeds. It’s 100% subjective and it’s designed to keep higher education exactly where it is: insulated, ideological, and untouchable.
Florida does things differently — and for that, this state takes a hit in “peer assessment.” Liberal politics, not performance, drives perception. Indeed, our state’s most pre-eminent state university, the University of Florida, has slipped this round as well, in both state and national rankings according to U.S. News.
Let’s talk about performance. In just two years, New College has achieved what most universities can’t do in a decade:
— We welcomed the largest student body in our history, which has more than 900 students.
— Applications rose 10%, while acceptance rates dropped below 65%, a selectivity rate that hasn’t been reached at New College for a decade.
— SAT scores jumped 4.5% to 1209, ACT scores rose to 25, and the average GPA climbed to nearly 4.0 — one of the strongest incoming classes in a decade.
— Graduate enrollment grew 67%, powered by groundbreaking programs in Applied Data Science and Marine Mammal Science.
— The Foundation Endowment grew from 39 million to 53 million in just three years.
These are not the signs of a struggling college. They’re the signs of one that’s roaring back to life.
And here’s what U.S. News won’t tell you: the rankings that include “retention” and “graduation rates” are still built on student data from the previous New College administration — data from the very years of failure we inherited. You can’t measure reform with yesterday’s numbers.
Let’s be clear: New College’s previous administrations failed the state, failed students and failed taxpayers. They neglected our infrastructure, enrollment and mission — and U.S. News would prefer we leave it that way. Reform threatens their entire system of cozy, left-wing, ideological self-approval.
We’ve just completed the second full year of a five-year plan to restore New College as Florida’s crown jewel of public liberal arts education — a place where elite students thrive through personal mentorship, independent study and rigorous academic freedom.
Our model hasn’t changed; it’s been renewed. The narrative evaluations, the faculty-student contract system, and the senior thesis — all remain at the core of what makes New College special. What has changed is accountability, excellence and energy.
We know where we’re going. We will become the #1 liberal arts college in the nation — not because we conform, but because we refuse to.
U.S. News can keep rewarding the old guard. We’ll keep building the future — one student, one class, and one idea at a time.
___
Richard Corcoran is president of New College of Florida.