As City Council members probe allegations surrounding an “illegal gun registry” at Jacksonville City Hall, the Mayor’s Office is declining to speak after being asked to appear voluntarily.
And subpoenas could be coming next.
What is known: There has been a requirement since 2023 for people carrying guns into Jacksonville’s public buildings to put their names, addresses and identifying information on what critics are dubbing a gun registry.
What isn’t known fully: who was responsible for said registry, and why it went on so long.
The Mayor’s Office isn’t saying much, but the facts are coming out nonetheless. And City Council members want to probe it internally.
The City Council Rules Committee explored that question. The General Counsel talked to legislators about the registry, which allegedly was maintained for nearly two years at both City Hall and the Yates Building by First Coast Security.
Republican critics of the list documenting those carrying guns violates state law. The effort was supposedly overseen by a private security company contracted by the city after July 1, 2023. That was the date when Mayor Donna Deegan took office.
Rules Chair Nick Howland cited Florida Statutes 790.335, which bans registries, noting these actions could lead to a third degree felony and a $5 million fine.
General Counsel Michael Fackler noted potential “serious consequences” for breach of the law, and said the Mayor’s Office was made aware of the issue on April 21 of this year.
A day later, subpoenas were served on the Mayor’s Office’s outside counsel at the Bedell Firm, which employs his father-in-law Hank Coxe. Fackler believes it is an investigative subpoena, rather than a grand jury product.
Outside counsel was hired, said Fackler, because criminal lawyers were needed for “the full panoply” of possibilities, including potential state charges.
“There are potentially significant sanctions as a result of the investigation,” he said.
Matt Carlucci wondered if the “tough little Mayor” was “guilty” and if Deegan initiated the registry; Fackler noted the investigation is “ongoing.”
“I don’t get the feeling that this is something she blindly went into to enforce,” he said. “I had a feeling there was no guilt yet because the due process of law hasn’t been exercised yet.”
He believes it’s “extremely unfair” that people say Deegan is guilty, because she hasn’t “had a chance to prove her innocence,” and urged people to be “careful” before blaming her for a practice underway for nearly two years since her inauguration.
Ron Salem was less credulous, saying the city charter allows for Council subpoenas, punishable by fines and investigations, a salient fact given that the Mayor’s Office did not voluntarily attend the meeting.
“We clearly have the ability to investigate this,” Salem said, likening it to the JEA sale attempt that was probed half a decade ago.
Fackler, who has been at odds with legislators since soon after they confirmed him in 2023, urged the City Council not to investigate the issue.
Jimmy Peluso said he was disappointed that Howland talked to the media, saying a “shade” meeting was more appropriate. He noted that in July 2023, a shade meeting was held to discuss the permitless carry law that went into effect at the beginning of that month and “what this government was going to do” about “the security plan.”
“It’s not a gun registry. It’s just not,” said the strong ally of the executive branch, who claimed no one objected to the list of gun owners back then.
“We learned about it in 2023 and none of you said anything. This is how I know it’s a total sham,” Peluso said.
“I’d caution us to be careful about who knew what when,” Fackler said, given the statute and the opening for “criminal or civil liability” if people spoke about this on the public record.
Citizens had their say as well.
Lawyer Eric Friday, the General Counsel of Florida Carry who is known for his staunch defense of the Second Amendment, was one of several citizens who criticized the list of lawful gun owners exercising their permitless carry rights.
He urged a “full and complete” probe by the State Attorney, and wants the City Council to crack down on the “felonious conduct” that abridged citizens’ rights to attend public meetings and enter public buildings without putting their names on a list.
Attorney General James Uthmeier and former Mayor Lenny Curry have spoken out against the alleged list making.
The Mayor has said the “policy in question was created and written before Mayor Deegan took office.”
Post Views: 0