Connect with us

Politics

Gulfstream Park asks high court to void 2021 decoupling law after being only parimutuel carved out

Published

on


First they pushed for legislative action. Now, they’re looking to the courts.

The Gulfstream Park Racing Association is asking the Florida Supreme Court to overturn the Decoupling Act passed by the Legislature in 2021, arguing it is unconstitutional because it aids rival slot machine operators.

The 2021 legislation decoupled all other parimutuel operators, seven in total, meaning they are allowed to operate slot machines at their facilities without having to run live racing or host jai alai.

Meanwhile, Gulfstream Park must meet specific requirements for thoroughbred racing in order to maintain its slot license. While Gulfstream Park is not the only thoroughbred racing facility in the state, it is the only one that operates slots, which means the law singled out its facility while allowing all others to operate under a different, more loose set of rules.

The lawsuit, filed by Gunster, Yoakley & Stewart against the Florida Gaming Control Commission, argues the law represents an unconstitutional special law, citing Article III, Section 10 of the state constitution, which bars passage of any special laws pertaining to a “grant of privilege to a private corporation.”

It further alleges that the law violates Gulfstream Park’s right to equal protection under the Florida Constitution, and its right under the constitution to operate slot machines.

The lawsuit asks for a declaration that the Decoupling Act was unconstitutional and a permanent injunction blocking the Florida Gaming Control Commission from requiring Gulfstream Park to run a full calendar of live racing as a condition for holding and maintaining its slot machine license, or from suspending its license for failing to be in compliance with the live racing requirements.

“The law on its face is anti-free markets, with the government picking winners and losers with its legislation,” said Marie Long, General Counsel for 1/ST, Gulfstream Park’s parent company.

“This is a matter of fair and equal treatment under the law, which the Decoupling Act clearly and intentionally violates. This is not about racing — we are committed to a sustainable future for racing. It’s about our inability to compete with the private slot operators who don’t have to meet the same obligations we must meet to run our business because they receive special treatment at our expense.”

The state first allowed parimutuel operators to have slot machines in 2004. At that time, all competitors were required to also operate live races — from harness to greyhound racing.

But after greyhound racing was banned in 2018, the state began allowing operators to maintain their slot licenses without offering live racing. That provision was memorialized in the 2021 law, but it carved out thoroughbred racing, directly blocking Gulfstream Park from being able to operate under the same rules as its competitors and thus, the lawsuit argues, offering an unfair advantage.

In addition to requiring live racing to maintain its slot permit, the law further implemented penalties to Gulfstream Park if it did not continue live racing under the law’s terms, including losing its slot license.

Gulfstream Park backed proposed legislation this year that would have decoupled thoroughbred racing from slot machine permit requirements, leveling the playing field for all parimutuel operators without singling out and disadvantaging Gulfstream Park. But the legislation failed, leaving operators to pursue a Plan B.

“We believe the Legislature can and should resolve this matter fairly and swiftly, however we are seeking relief from the Court to protect and uphold the Constitutional rights granted to us by Florida voters in 2005,” Long said.

“Florida has long been recognized as a business-friendly state, and we urge it to maintain that reputation. In this case, the approach taken is inconsistent with that tradition. While we hope the Legislature acts promptly, we ask the Courts to ensure fairness and protect the principles of a free and competitive market.”


Post Views: 0



Source link

Continue Reading

Politics

Hope Florida fallout drives another Rick Scott rebuke of Ron DeSantis

Published

on


The cold war between Florida’s Governor and his predecessor is nearly seven years old and tensions show no signs of thawing.

On Friday, Sen. Rick Scott weighed in on Florida Politics’ reporting on the Agency for Health Care Administration’s apparent repayment of $10 million of Medicaid money from a settlement last year, which allegedly had been diverted to the Hope Florida Foundation, summarily filtered through non-profits through political committees, and spent on political purposes.

“I appreciate the efforts by the Florida legislature to hold Hope Florida accountable. Millions in tax dollars for poor kids have no business funding political ads. If any money was misspent, then it should be paid back by the entities responsible, not the taxpayers,” Scott posted to X.

While AHCA Deputy Chief of Staff Mallory McManus says that is an “incorrect” interpretation, she did not respond to a follow-up question asking for further detail this week.

The $10 million under scrutiny was part of a $67 million settlement from state Medicaid contractor Centene, which DeSantis said was “a cherry on top” in the settlement, arguing it wasn’t truly from Medicaid money.

But in terms of the Scott-DeSantis contretemps, it’s the latest example of tensions that seemed to start even before DeSantis was sworn in when Scott left the inauguration of his successor, and which continue in the race to succeed DeSantis, with Scott enthusiastic about current front runner Byron Donalds.

Earlier this year, Scott criticized DeSantis’ call to repeal so-called vaccine mandates for school kids, saying parents could already opt out according to state law.

While running for re-election to the Senate in 2024, Scott critiqued the Heartbeat Protection Act, a law signed by DeSantis that banned abortion after the sixth week of pregnancy with some exceptions, saying the 15 week ban was “where the state’s at.”

In 2023 after Scott endorsed Donald Trump for President while DeSantis was still a candidate, DeSantis said it was an attempt to “short circuit” the voters.

That same year amid DeSantis’ conflict over parental rights legislation with The Walt Disney Co.Scott said it was important for Governors to “work with” major companies in their states.

The critiques went both ways.

When running for office, DeSantis distanced himself from Scott amid controversy about the Senator’s blind trust for his assets as Governor.

“I basically made decisions to serve in uniform, as a prosecutor, and in Congress to my financial detriment,” DeSantis said in October 2018. “I’m not entering (office) with a big trust fund or anything like that, so I’m not going to be entering office with those issues.”

In 2020, when the state’s creaky unemployment website couldn’t handle the surge of applicants for reemployment assistance as the pandemic shut down businesses, DeSantis likened it to a “jalopy in the Daytona 500” and Scott urged him to “quit blaming others” for the website his administration inherited.

The chill between the former and current Governors didn’t abate in time for 2022’s hurricane season, when Scott said DeSantis didn’t talk to him after the fearsome Hurricane Ian ravaged the state.



Source link

Continue Reading

Politics

Amnesty International alleges human rights violations at Alligator Alcatraz

Published

on


Enforcing what Gov. Ron DeSantis calls the “rule of law” violates international law and norms, according to a global group weighing in this week.

Amnesty International is the latest group to condemn the treatment of immigrants with disputed documentation at two South Florida lockups, the Krome North Service Processing Center (Krome) and the Everglades Detention Facility (Alligator Alcatraz).

The latter has been a priority of state government since President Donald Trump was inaugurated.

The organization claims treatment of the detained falls “far below international human rights standards.”

Amnesty released a report Friday covering what it calls a “a research trip to southern Florida in September 2025, to document the human rights impacts of federal and state migration and asylum policies on mass detention and deportation, access to due process, and detention conditions since President Trump took office on 20 January 2025.”

“The routine and prolonged use of shackles on individuals detained for immigration purposes, both at detention facilities and during transfer between facilities, constitutes cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment, and may amount to torture or other ill-treatment,” the report concludes.

Gov. DeSantis’ administration spent much of 2025 prioritizing Alligator Alcatraz.

While the state did not comment on the report, Amnesty alleges the state’s “decision to cut resources from essential social and emergency management programs while continuing to allocate resources for immigration detention represents a grave misallocation of state resources. This practice undermines the fulfillment of economic and social rights for Florida residents and reinforces a system of detention that facilitates human rights violations.”

Amnesty urges a series of policy changes that won’t happen, including the repeal of immigration legislation in Senate Bill 4-C, which proscribes penalties for illegal entry and illegal re-entry, mandates imprisonment for being in Florida without being a legal immigrant, and capital punishment for any such undocumented immigrant who commits capital crimes.

The group also recommends ending 287(g) agreements allowing locals to help with immigration enforcement, stopping practices like shackling and solitary confinement, and closing Alligator Alcatraz itself.



Source link

Continue Reading

Politics

Dr. Phillips Center’s free holiday festival transforms Orlando

Published

on


In one year of planning, the Dr. Phillips Center for the Performing Arts Center has pulled off an extraordinary feat: It has turned the heart of downtown into a magical Winter festival.

“It’s amazing. I had no idea just what the transformation would be,” said Orlando Mayor Buddy Dyer during a preview for the media and local officials this week for the first-ever Frontyard Holiday Festival supported by AdventHealth.

Fire pits glow. Singers perform on stage. Fake snow falls down for the Florida kids who don’t know the real thing. Holiday booths sell coquito, sandwiches and hearty snacks. It’s easy to forget that the 408 traffic is in the backdrop or ignore an ambulance siren going by. Instead, you get lost in Santa greeting children and the music on stage from Central Florida’s talent.

The free festival, which is officially open, runs 28 days through Jan. 4 and will feature 80 live performances, holiday movies, nightly tree lightings and more. The slate of performers includes opera singers, high school choirs, jazz performers, Latin Night and more. The schedule is available here.

About 300,000 people are expected to attend — a boon to the city’s economy especially since one 1 of every 4 Dr. Phillips Center visitors typically comes from outside Orange County, said Orange County Commissioner Mike Scott.

Most importantly, this festival builds connections,” Scott said. “This festival creates a cultural and economic ripple that extends well beyond the borders of downtown.”

The performing arts center has hosted “Lion King,” “Hamilton” and more during its 10 years in business. But during the pandemic, it began using the space out front — its “front yard” — in innovative ways, said Kathy Ramsberger, President and CEO of Dr. Phillips Center.

Keeping patrons spread apart in individual seat boxes, Dr. Phillips held concerts outdoors during the pandemic.

Ramsberger said the Dr. Phillips Center purposefully has chosen not to develop the land in order to keep the space for people to come together.

“Hopefully, this will grow across the street to City Hall, down the street, over to Orange County administration building, up and down Orange Avenue, and the entire city will be connected with something that the City of Orlando started to celebrate Christmas and the holidays,” Ramsberger said.



Source link

Continue Reading

Trending

Copyright © Miami Select.