Connect with us

Politics

Federal court rejects Joe Carollo appeal, raising questions about potential removal from office

Published

on


In a major legal blow to Miami Commissioner Joe Carollo, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit has dismissed his appeal of a $63.5 million judgment for retaliatory conduct against two local businessmen.

The ruling marks the latest — and potentially final — turn in a yearslong legal saga that could now have serious ethical and political consequences for Carollo.

William “Bill” Fuller and Martin Pinilla II, two Miami businessmen, sued Carollo in 2018, alleging that he used city agencies to target their businesses in retaliation for their support of his political opponent during the 2017 municipal elections.

After a 24-day trial in 2023, a federal jury found that Carollo had indeed violated the businessmen’s First Amendment rights, awarding millions in compensatory and punitive damages. Carollo challenged the verdict on multiple fronts, including alleged jury tampering and excessive damages.

But in its July 17 decision, the 11th Circuit firmly rejected Carollo’s arguments. Writing for the panel, the court concluded that the lower court had “sufficiently investigated Carollo’s claims of jury tampering” and that the interaction in question was “harmless.” The court also found it lacked jurisdiction to review Carollo’s other claims because of procedural missteps in his notice of appeal.

“The district court properly responded to and investigated Juror 3’s contact with (a member of the plaintiffs’ circle),” the panel wrote. “Once it completed that investigation, the district court took appropriate measures to ensure the jury remained fair and impartial to both parties.”

The decision raises immediate questions about Carollo’s status as a public official. Legal experts say the civil judgment — along with the appellate court’s affirmation — may open the door to action under Florida Statute 112.51, which permits the Governor to suspend or remove elected officials for malfeasance, misfeasance, or neglect of duty.

“This is no longer a political dispute or just a civil case — it’s a validated court finding of intentional harm by an elected official using the power of his office,” said one Miami-based legal ethicist who requested his name be withheld. “That’s the textbook definition of malfeasance under Florida law.”

Florida Statute 112.51 defines malfeasance as “an intentional act that is illegal and causes physical or monetary harm to another party.” With more than $60 million in damages upheld by the courts, some experts argue that the threshold has been met.

Moreover, the city of Miami may be forced to reconsider its financial support of Carollo’s legal defense. To date, taxpayers have footed the bill for his attorneys — costs that are only legally defensible if Carollo acted within the scope of his official duties.

“This ruling essentially confirms that Carollo acted outside his lawful authority, which could mean the city is no longer obligated — or even permitted — to continue paying his legal fees,” said a government accountability expert familiar with municipal ethics rules.

It is expected that over the coming days, advocacy groups and local leaders will start privately exploring the process of petitioning the Governor’s Office to consider suspension proceedings, citing the court’s finding as grounds for removal.

As one legal analyst noted, “There’s only so long an elected official can carry the weight of a $60 million judgment before the system — or the voters — respond.”

We tried to reach out to Carollo for comment on the ruling. We will update with any comments.


Post Views: 0



Source link

Continue Reading

Politics

Debra Tendrich turns ‘pain into policy’ with sweeping anti-domestic violence proposal

Published

on


Florida could soon rewrite how it responds to domestic violence.

Lake Worth Democratic Rep. Debra Tendrich has filed HB 277, a sweeping proposal aimed at modernizing the state’s domestic violence laws with major reforms to prevention, first responder training, court safeguards, diversion programs and victim safety.

It’s a deeply personal issue to Tendrich, who moved to Florida in 2012 to escape what she has described as a “domestic violence situation,” with only her daughter and a suitcase.

“As a survivor myself, HB 277 is more than legislation; it is my way of turning pain into policy,” she said in a statement, adding that months of roundtables with survivors and first responders “shaped this bill from start to finish.”

Tendrich said that, if passed, HB 277 or its upper-chamber analogue (SB 682) by Miami Republican Sen. Alexis Calatayud would become Florida’s most comprehensive domestic violence initiative, covering prevention, early intervention, criminal accountability and survivor support.

It would require mandatory strangulation and domestic violence training for emergency medical technicians and paramedics, modernize the legal definition of domestic violence, expand the courts’ authority to order GPS monitoring and strengthen body camera requirements during investigations.

The bill also creates a treatment-based diversion pathway for first-time offenders who plead guilty and complete a batterers intervention program, mental-health services and weekly court-monitored progress reporting. Upon successful completion, charges could be dismissed, a measure Tendrich says will reduce recidivism while maintaining accountability.

On the victim-safety side, HB 277 would flag addresses for 12 months after a domestic-violence 911 call to give responders real-time risk awareness. It would also expand access to text-to-911, require pamphlets detailing the medical dangers of strangulation, authorize well-check visits tied to lethality assessments, enhance penalties for repeat offenders and include pets and service animals in injunctions to prevent coercive control and harm.

Calatayud called it “a tremendous honor and privilege” to work with Tendrich on advancing policy changes “that both law enforcement and survivors of domestic abuse or relationship violence believe are meaningful to protect families across our communities.”

“I’m deeply committed to championing these essential reforms,” she added, saying they would make “a life-or-death difference for women and children in Florida.”

Organizations supporting HB 277 say the bill reflects long-needed, practical reform. Palm Beach County firefighters union IAFF Local 2928 said expanded responder training and improved dispatch information “is exactly the kind of frontline-focused reform that saves lives.”

The Florida Police Benevolent Association called HB 277 a “comprehensive set of measures designed to enhance protections” and pledged to help advance it through the Legislature.

The Animal Legal Defense Fund praised provisions protecting pets in domestic violence cases, noting research showing that 89% of women with pets in abusive relationships have had partners threaten or harm their animals — a major barrier that keeps victims from fleeing.

Florida continues to see high levels of domestic violence. The National Coalition Against Domestic Violence estimates that 38% of Florida women and 29% of Florida men experience intimate-partner violence in their lifetimes — among the highest rates in the country.

With costs rising statewide, HB 277 also increases relocation assistance through the Crimes Compensation Trust Fund, which advocates say is essential because the current $1,500 cap no longer covers basic expenses for victims fleeing dangerous situations.

Tendrich said survivors who contributed to the bill, which Placida Republican Rep. Danny Nix is co-sponsoring, “finally feel seen.”

“This bill will save lives,” she said. “I am proud that this bill has bipartisan support, and I am even more proud of the survivors whose bravery drives every line of this legislation.”



Source link

Continue Reading

Politics

Ash Marwah, Ralph Massullo battle for SD 11 Special Election

Published

on


Even Ash Marwah knows the odds do him no favors.

A Senate district that leans heavily Republican plus a Special Election just weeks before Christmas — Marwah acknowledges it adds up to a likely Tuesday victory for Ralph Massullo.

The Senate District 11 Special Election is Tuesday to fill the void created when Blaise Ingoglia became Chief Financial Officer.

It pits Republican Massullo, a dermatologist and Republican former four-term House member from Lecanto, against Democrat Marwah, a civil engineer from The Villages.

Early voter turnout was light, as would be expected in a low-key standalone Special Election: At 10% or under for Hernando and Pasco counties, 19% in Sumter and 15% in Citrus.

Massullo has eyed this Senate seat since 2022 when he originally planned to leave the House after six years for the SD 11 run. His campaign ended prematurely when Gov. Ron DeSantis backed Ingoglia, leaving Massullo with a final two years in office before term limits ended his House career.

When the SD 11 seat opened up with Ingoglia’s CFO appointment, Massullo jumped in and a host of big-name endorsements followed, including from DeSantis, Ingoglia, Agriculture Commissioner Wilton Simpson, U.S. Sens. Ashley Moody and Rick Scott, four GOP Congressmen, county Sheriffs in the district, and the Florida Chamber of Commerce.

The Florida LGBTQ+ Democratic Caucus is endorsing Marwah.

Marwah ran for HD 52 in 2024, garnering just 24% of the vote against Republican John Temple

Massullo has raised $249,950 to Marwah’s $12,125. Massullo’s $108,000 in spending includes consulting, events and mail pieces. One of those mail pieces reminded voters there’s an election.

The two opponents had few opportunities for head-to-head debate. The League of Women Voters of Citrus County conducted a SD 11 forum on Zoom in late October, when the two candidates clashed over the state’s direction.

Marwah said DeSantis and Republicans are “playing games” in their attempts to redraw congressional district boundaries.

“No need to go through this expense,” he said. “It will really ruin decades of progress in civil rights. We should honor the rule of law that we agreed on that it’ll be done every 10 years. I’m not sure why the game is being played at this point.”

Massullo said congressional districts should reflect population shifts.

“The people of our state deserve to be adequately represented based on population,” he said. “I personally do not believe we should use race as a means to justify particular areas. I’m one that believes we should be blind to race, blind to creed, blind to sex, in everything that we do, particularly looking at population.”

Senate District 11 covers all of Citrus, Hernando and Sumter counties, plus a portion of northern Pasco County. It is safely Republican — Ingoglia won 69% of the vote there in November, and Donald Trump carried the district by the same margin in 2024.



Source link

Continue Reading

Politics

Miles Davis tapped to lead School Board organizing workshop at national LGBTQ conference

Published

on


Miles Davis is taking his Florida-focused organizing playbook to the national stage.

Davis, Policy Director at PRISM Florida and Director of Advocacy and Communications at SAVE, has been selected to present a workshop at the 2026 Creating Change Conference, the largest annual LGBTQ advocacy and movement-building convention.

It’s a major nod to his rising role in Florida’s LGBTQ policy landscape.

The National LGBTQ Task Force, which organizes the conference, announced that Davis will present his session, “School Board Organizing 101.” His proposal rose to the top of more than 550 submissions competing for roughly 140 slots, a press note said, making this year’s conference one of the most competitive program cycles in the event’s history.

His workshop will be scheduled during the Jan. 21-24 gathering in Washington, D.C.

Davis said his selection caps a strong year for PRISM Florida, where he helped shepherd the organization’s first-ever bill (HB 331) into the Legislature. The measure, sponsored by Tampa Democratic Rep. Dianne Hart, would restore local oversight over reproductive health and HIV/AIDS instruction, undoing changes enacted under a 2023 expansion to Florida’s “Parental Rights in Education” law, dubbed “Don’t Say Gay” by critics.

Davis’ workshop draws directly from that work and aims to train LGBTQ youth, families and advocates in how local boards operate, how public comment can shape decisions and how communities can mobilize around issues like book access, inclusive classrooms and student safety.

“School boards are where the real battles over student safety, book access, and inclusive classrooms are happening,” Davis said. “I’m honored to bring this training to Creating Change and help our community build the skills to show up, speak out, and win — especially as PRISM advances legislation like HB 331 that returns power to our local communities.”

Davis’ profile has grown in recent years, during which he jumped from working on the campaigns and legislative teams of lawmakers like Hart and Miami Gardens Democratic Sen. Shevrin Jones to working in key roles for organizations like America Votes, PRISM and SAVE.

The National LGBTQ Task Force, founded in 1973, is one of the nation’s oldest LGBTQ advocacy organizations. It focuses on advancing civil rights through federal policy work, grassroots engagement and leadership development.

Its Creating Change Conference draws thousands for four days of training and strategy-building yearly, a press note said.



Source link

Continue Reading

Trending

Copyright © Miami Select.