An Op-Ed By Commissioner Chris Boles

The crack of the bat is usually a sound of pure optimism, but in the case of the Tampa Bay Rays’ stadium deal, it has triggered a frantic scramble in the bleachers.

As soon as the preliminary plans for a new ballpark at the Hillsborough Community College site were announced, the public discourse shifted into overdrive. Critics decry the use of public funds as a billionaire bailout, while boosters hail it as the only way to save Major League Baseball in the region. The intensity of these reactions reflects how much is at stake, but it also underscores the need for clarity over speed.

Before we declare this deal a home run or a strikeout, we should take a moment to fully understand what is being proposed.

Jumping to conclusions before the final details are inked is a classic “foul ball,” and this commissioner would encourage everyone to return to the dugout before we can fairly argue the merits of any proposed deal.

The primary reason for restraint should be anchored in the sheer complexity of public financing.

Stadium deals are rarely as simple as a single check written by taxpayers. They typically involve intricate webs of Community Investment Taxes, Community Redevelopment Area (CRA) funds, bed taxes, which are paid by tourists, not residents, and long-term land value appreciation and revenue generation. To judge the deal based on a headline figure is to ignore the “waterfall” of revenue streams that can, if properly structured, insulate taxpayers from long-term risk.

Skepticism is not only understandable but also warranted given how similar deals have played out elsewhere. That is precisely why the full financial breakdown should be released, scrutinized, and vetted, with complete transparency before any conclusions are drawn.

Furthermore, the stadium is only one piece of this massive redevelopment. This isn’t just about a diamond and some dugouts; it’s about thousands of units of housing, office spaces, and a long-overdue attempt to jumpstart the economic fabric of an area lacking an economic engine.

We must wait to see the ironclad guarantees regarding affordable housing and minority-owned business participation. If the deal ensures that the Rays’ presence acts as a true catalyst, as projected, the “cost” of the stadium looks very different than if it were a standalone monolith surrounded by parking lots.

There is also the matter of the Rays’ own contribution. In an era where many owners demand the moon while offering pocket change, the reported private investment from the Rays’ ownership is substantial and should be carefully evaluated alongside the public commitment.

In this case, the devil is most certainly in the details, and we should all head back to the dugout because, in the end, we are all on the same team.

Public passion is the lifeblood of sports, but it is a poor substitute for disciplined fiscal analysis.

We live in an era of “hot takes”, where being first to complain is often valued more than being right. But a multi-billion-dollar redevelopment project that could redefine Drew Park and the Dale Mabry Sports Corridor for the next half-century deserves more than a knee-jerk reaction.

Let your elected officials and financial analysts do their due diligence, but demand that it be rigorous, transparent, and grounded. Then let’s all sit down and determine whether a deal is truly worthy of all our trust.

Until the final box score is in, let’s keep our eyes on the ball and wait for the full data set to cross the plate.

___

County Commissioner Chris Boles was elected in November 2024 to represent Countywide District 6 on the Hillsborough County Board of County Commissioners.